Microsoft has mentioned recently that Game Pass is becoming a viable “thing” on its own. For a lot of smaller developers and publishers, many have cited that being on Game Pass brought their game a level of exposure that probably would not have been able to get otherwise.
But in Nintendo’s case, and the case of the “Classic Games”? The biggest problem I see is that a LOT of game companies just have relatively little appreciation (for lack of a better word) for their own legacies. I was a left a bit flabbergasted when a Sony exec (the CEO even?) remarked how the PlayStation platform was lacking in franchises…despite DOZENS of legacy franchises that could have been explored. Sega has PILES of wonderful arcade games from the mid-late 90s that have been forgotten to time because they were never ported (a big appeal of the Yakuza games IS the fact they have these old arcade games hidden within them). And most of the western game companies have become so greedy and live-service centric, most don’t even bother remembering their own back catalogs.
I fully believe there is a big market for a “retro gaming subscription service” akin to Game Pass. But I think it would require so much time and money and a LOT of leg work to get all the different companies on board that I don’t think any of the big players feel it is “worth it”. As is, what little interest there might be, each company seems to want “their own slice” rather than working together to make a bigger pie.
Even skipping Nintendo, If you could get Sega, Konami, Atari and SNK all together? You could probably get away with a solid $15 a month with a rotating catalog of titles up to the 32 bit era. Even disregarding licensed stuff, Sega’s Master System to Saturn titles, much less Dreamcast, represent a HUGE library. Not to mention the arcade flavors and the Atlus back catalog. Konami brings dozens more PLUS the Turbografx library. Atari will license out to anybody, but their 2600, 7800, Lynx, Jaguar and Intellivision libraries are nothing to scoff at. And if they managed to get EA on board? There’s some solid console gaming to be had.
Problem is that someone has to get them all together under a single banner and THAT is the hard part.