Toy shelf head Canon

Destron D-69

at Journey's end
Citizen
I want to open a discussion about the little stories we tell ourselves about the toys we buy... not full on fanfic, just the justifications we come up with for owning 3 slightly different versions of the same character...or likely more for a lot of us.


For example... magenta and Red studio series Hotrods... my shelf Canon is that Magenta Hotrod is pre-matrix hotrod and Red Hotrod is Post-Rodimus Hotrod.
 

LordGigaIce

Another babka?
Citizen
It depends. I had red SS '86 Hot Rod but he got put in storage when I got magenta Hot Rod. I still have Kingdom Rodimus out and there's a whole Prime upgrade thing going on there.

Usually if I get multiples of one character on the shelf, I try to repurpose one unless it's clearly a different form of the same design. Like how Legacy Cybertron Hot Shot is Hot Shot and AotP Red Excellion is... well... Excellion.

Or how I have three versions of Alpha Trion. AotP Alpha Trion with the Thirteen, Legacy two pack Alpha Trion with my main Autobot display, and TR Alpha Trion with my Autobot Knights as Alpha Trizer, who is an updated version of Cheetor, whose Netflix Deluxe is chilling with the rest of the Maximals.

There's no rhyme or reason to this, it's just vibes.
 
Last edited:

Sciflyer

Two arms and one smile
Citizen
I used to have a much larger collection of black deco'd Transformers that occupied a prominent spot on my shelf. I loved tracking down decos, mixing and matching eras, making a mostly-Decepticon team of special agents. I still have a good chunk of them, but examples include: United Wipe Out, RID Scourge, G2 Road Pig, Antagony, Scamper - even Night Slash Cheetor because I'm a sick man!
 

Arazyr

Active member
Citizen
My "Shelf Canon" is basically just the canon of My World (TM), and there's a fair amount of it. But the one bit that comes to mind right away, and is probably short enough to type up right now:

T30 Jetfire (technically, the Revolution boxed set version) is Jetfire, and Siege Jetfire is Skyfire. They are brothers; Jetfire is older, but physically smaller. Their "father"/mentor wanted both of them to go into the Cybertronian Air Force like he did. Jetfire happily did so, but Skyfire disappointed dad when he wanted to go to the science academy. Jetfire, though, is his "little" brother's biggest supporter, and managed to run interference enough to get Skyfire admittance. He was always so enthusiastic about his brother's interests that he became essentially a Cybertronian version of the "I F***ing Love Science!" guy, using the most advanced flying and weapons tech available.

They both joined the Autobots after the war broke out, with Skyfire working in Autobot Engineering on advanced weapon systems, so they both now have a foot in each world, even though they each focus on a different one.
 

unluckiness

Somehow still sane
Citizen
My shelf canon would be a mess. The Thirteen Primes live next to the Power Rangers who are upstairs from the super robots, while Megaman and Megaman X crash at Unicron and his minions' shelf because they don't have enough merch to warrant their own yet. Also King Ghidorah lives with a bunch of Core/Legends robots because the other Kaiju kicked him out of their shelf for his gigantic wingspan.
 

Platypus Prime

Well-known member
Citizen
Weirdly, one idea I came up with when I was five and got my first Transformer (Thundercracker) without seeing any sort of fiction was the idea of interdimensional energy creatures getting into machines and reshaping them into bodies. Not too different from the later ideas of Sparks, or how the Combaticons rebuilt old junk into new forms by having their components put inside them.

Later on, I thought the Great War would end if someone invented a self-regenerating energy supply, so in my head, all my characters were at Toy Scale, no matter what the alt mode was, justified by making 'size change' incompatible with perpetual energy. So you can run forever, or grow and shrink, but not both. It's also why I have some Decepticons and Autobots together, as it ended a long time ago and no one cares. Megatron's Double Pretender shares a shell with Cerebros.

More modern times, in my own head I had Devestator, Frame Bruticus, Dinoking, and other 'fixed' combiners as much more intelligent, strong, and stable than the Scramble sorts, because they always have their components assemble the same way every time. Not remotely fiction accurate, I know, but I've always been much more toy-interested than fiction. I know about it, but for my own shelves, the stories never overwrote my own preferences, they just gave me extra material I took or left randomly at different times.

Besides, any and all fiction is Kup's war stories, probably after he was out of it on unfiltered tap water again. So any discrepancy in continuity, characters, animation errors, etc. are just an unreliable narrator with a shotgun, a drinking habit, and a robot pug dog with severe scoliosis politely called "The Tootinator".
 

Jackpot

Neo-maxi zoom dweebie
Citizen
I've always been drawn to figures that have different-environment alt-modes, for this reason. Like, a character whose traditional representation is Cybertronian/futuristic having an Earth mode or vice-versa. It suggests storylines inherently. For instance, I got Cyber Battalion Megatron because it was the first Cybertronian-styled Megatron toy I thought looked good enough to own. (Side note: apparently that toy doesn't exist anywhere on the wiki?)
 

Haywire

Collecter of Gobots and Godzilla
Citizen
My collection has 2 scales: Gobot scale and TF scale. Gobot scale is pretty self-explanatory, and any TF duplication I can write off as generics.

TF scale gets broken up into "teams", some of which will be obvious ('84-'85 Autobots and Decepticons, Agents of Unicron, Constructicons, Aerialbots, etc), but some have some interesting backstories.
-Decepticon Earthforce is led by RiD Scourge, but many of his subordinates are Nemesis Primes. Apparently, Megatron thought this was hilarious. This team also includes a lot of Decepticons who seem to be Renegades at heart, like Fracture, Crasher, Deadlift, and SE Dragstrip who goes by the nickname Slicks...
-Iacon Defense Force, led by Classics Ultra Magnus, includes a lot of Cybertronian Mode Transformers. A lot of my duplicate Transformers wind up in this group as generic soldiers.
-Wreckers, not exactly composed of the standard Wreckers roster, this team includes very combat-ready Autobots, such as Cybertron Defense Hot Shot and several tank transformers.
-Club D.A.N.G. (Didn't Appear iN G1) led by President Powerlinx Hot Shot (with a regular Hot Shot head) and First Tiger Jet Hooligan, members include Transmetal Waspinator (Waspy) and RtS Lugnut (The 'Nut), Decepticon Hatchet, Rosanna, Sundor, and Glit, and many more. Members get a cool paper hat.
 

lastmaximal

Administrator
Staff member
Council of Elders
Citizen
This is more for the collection in general since the "display" is basically "there was a flat surface and a currently-opened/out toy".

So much repurposing. And in some cases weird mixes of old and new characters. It helps to avoid just flat-out admitting that I bought way too many of the damn things, sometimes with pretty slim differences.

Why is there a toy-based Gears and a cartoon-based Gears? I couldn't resist having both looks and the masked one was a decent deal One is a battle-masked one from Cybertron, where the different atmosphere makes his paint look different Multiverse, yo.

Too many movie Drifts. AOE Voyager copter Drift, Red/black Studio Series Drift, blue/black AOE Drift, and Studio Series copter Drift? Council Of Drifts The AOE Voyager is Yoketron or a similar legendary ancestor, the two blue/black ones are present-day monk-ish twin acolytes, and the red/black one is a present-day descendant, inheritor of the art/abilities/name. Or something.

Animated Blurr went to Velocitron and reformatted into Cybertron Blurr to win the Speedia 500.

Ramjet is a jerk who, upon taking his Seeker reinforcement squad to Earth, forced Dirge and Thrust to take smaller conehead forms (the Armada Thrust redecos) while he had a hulking, brutish robot mode (ROTF Ramjet).

Soundwave and Friends just upgrade to different forms over time. The cassettes develop into more independent operatives and altmodes (the TAV tanks, etc). Still toying with ideas for RID2015 and Earthspark/NL Soundwave to be a tandem of Soundwave fans/operatives/decoys.

Still thinking of something for the multiple Starscream/Skywarp/Thundercracker sets that are (color schemes aside, mostly) "distinct enough" (Armada, Prime/Arms Micron, FOC...)

Optimus Prime dies and there's a Reign of the Supermen Optimus Primes situation where pieces of his spark temporarily manifest in four different forms. At one point this was the Animated Cybertron mode Deluxe, the Energon Costco exclusive emergency striped Armada redeco, Beast Machines Primal Prime, and Sam's Club yellow RID2001 Optimus Prime.
 

Cybersnark

Well-known member
Citizen
There are multiple Megatrons running around (not all of whom are actually represented on my shelves);
Galvatron used to be G1 Megatron.
AEC Megatron used to be Megaplex (he's [probably] dead now).
Animated Megatron is G1 Cyclonus, masquerading as the original Megatron to pursue his own agenda.
Megaempress is Flamewar in her "mark 1" Megatron cosplay disguise; she rejects the "false" Megatron, and believes that the "real" Megatron is still out there somewhere (she's out of the loop on Galvatron).

"Soundwave" is no longer just Soundwave.
At some point he discovered artifacts belonging to Logos Prime, and learned how to share his consciousness between multiple bodies.
There's a Soundwave on Cybertron, working with (Ani) Megatron as part of the new multi-faction government.
There's a Soundwave on Earth working with the Decepticons led by Scourge (who think Scourge is passing on orders from Galvatron).
There's a Soundwave in deep space, with Galvatron, working to rebuild his empire.
He also has "puppets" among the Autobots, Renegades, and Starscream's Guardians, including Shatter, whose broken body was recovered by the EDC and rebuilt into a mindless drone before Soundwave "liberated" it (everybody assumes she has PTSD and doesn't talk anymore, but "Shatter" is actually long dead).

The Guardians (Decepticons who've cut a deal to defend Earth as-is as their new homeworld) include Starscream, Shatter, (Cyb)Demolisher, (Prime)Knock-Out, and (Studio Series)Widowmaker (serving as Knock-Out's long-suffering secretary/bodyguard).
 

LBD "Nytetrayn"

Broke the Matrix
Staff member
Council of Elders
Citizen
I have two of the Kingdom Galvatron mold, the toy colors one and the one from Legacy without the scuffs on it.

One is a reformatted Megatron.

The other is a unique character, more akin to IDW or the OG tech specs.

Which is which changes on a whim depending on how much I'm into the idea of Galvatron's colors resembling Megatron's or being like the cartoon or whatever.
 

Sabrblade

Continuity Nutcase
Citizen
I have four versions of the Kingdom Galvatron mold:
  • Legacy (purple w/ no scuffs): His own person, a la IDW Galvatron
  • Selects (gray toy colors): Galvatron II or Marvel UK Galvatron (depending on my mood; mostly just "Marvel-esque Galvatron from an alternate future")
  • Studio Series 86 (blurple): G1 Cartoon Megatron reformatted
  • Behold: Galvatron (translucent purple): Immortal ghost Galvatron/living embodiment of the "G-Virus" (largely inspired by the absolutely ruthless "Destroyer of Worlds" description of Galvatron from Beast Wars: Uprising)
 
Top Bottom