Yeah I'm the type of person who's brain thinks logically, and likes to break things down in such a specific way that when playing games it's basically going: "Okay what reason would there be for the game to do this?" And better yet "What would it mean if a bad thing happened?"
The answer is nothing for that last one. My brain is constantly on: "This is a videogame" mentality. So it doesn't matter if a bad thing happens. It's not going to affect me personally. Why be afraid of something that can't hurt me in anyway?
I do have some horror movies, but it's usually a horror comedy, or I just found the set up neat. Can't say there are any that really spooked me. (I'm one of those people who can go to sleep listening to youtube videos "3 true scary in the woods stories"
To possibly put the nail in the coffin so to speak. You are also talking to someone who played through Resident Evil 7 completely IN VR. The VR ended up being it's only saving grace. I find the rest of the game to be rather bland.
The only monster you get is the stupid molded in like four or five different forms. BORING.
The infected house residents are alright. Jack is your typical stalker, and the wife is a decent monster, but I'd prefer to have found actual giant insects or something. Give me the infected giant snake, or a Hunter!
Then the son character was just a dumb SAW parody. I could do with that entire section just being cut. That's not Resident Evil.
The DLC ironically was the only thing that actually got to me, and that's because it connects to something I can't control. A phobia I have.
Infected crocodiles in the swamp. Creatures that can swim/ or live in the water that can kill you TERRIFY me.
There is a really bad horror game for the PS4 that has PS2 like graphics (which I can't remember what it's called) but you are in some underwater building where SHARKS have gotten in, and that would scare the hell out of me. I hate sharks, I hate fish with teeth. I hate being in water! >_<
THIS is what terrified me as a kid.