So, I saw the movie (btw, my local theatre was already sold out of most of the swag. Not sure that bodes well for me getting the Castle Grayskull bucket).
It was…okay. But, like, a GOOD okay. If I had been truly able to turn off my “nerd brain”, I would even be willing to call it excellent.
Broadly, it was a fun couple hours with a bad ass bounty hunter. Think too hard, and it’s clear that the project is some Frankenstein of season 4 concepts and differing corporate strategies. It follows season 3…but it doesn’t really rely on much knowledge of the franchise besides what is well known in popular culture (and a VERY brief blurb at the start). It is VERY accessible, but doesn’t really change the dynamic of the character that might carry into another potential season. But it also feels more “classically Star Wars” than many of the other Disney projects, especially the sequel trilogy. The film knows when to just “get out of its own way” and trust the audience will buy into this world and characters. It doesn’t bog itself down with unnecessary exposition, but it shows enough for inattentive audiences to grasp things like the character dynamics and the different settings. There is just a sense of “wonder” that other Star Wars projects kind of forget in service of THE LORE.
That said, I was left wanting AS A STAR WARS NERD because the film does touch on some interesting ideas concerning species longevity and how that impacts future generations. Much of this felt like a framework for a full 8-episode season, where I think a LOT of these quiet moments and ideas could be more easily expanded upon. Then again, a standard TV season might not have the budget for some of the great action sequences that were put to film. Rotta the Hutt actually turned into a decent new character to the canon, despite his inglorious start back in the Clone Wars 2009 pilot film.
In some respects, the film reminds me a bit of an anime compilation film, where they took episode highlights, added/expanded some animation sequences and released it as a film. Compare Macross Plus’s 4 episode OVA series to its film version to get an idea of what I mean.
Is it bad? No…if you go in with adjusted expectations. I think this paraphrase from Bob “MovieBob” Chipman sums up the film quite well: “It has puppets, monsters, lasers and spaceships. What the eff else you want?” But I still question whether or not all this really warranted a film push besides Disney REALLY jonesing for some sort of “win” after the response to the last couple theatrical films and seeming disinterest in the streaming projects.
Sidebar: Nerdy stuff! Another thing Bob Chipman remarked was how this like a “toy box movie”, and I kind of agree! For long time fans, seeing the old mini-rig the INT-4 and the old Amanaman get used in a modern media project is another level of fan service. The Amanaman species was used to GREAT effect and it’s sad that Hasbro likely won’t be doing any sort of fresh toy with this exposure in the near term. Lots of big monsters and great droid mercenary designs that will probably never get toys because of the “way” toy companies operate these days. Outside of Lego.