I think it's similar to BioWare. Politics may well have played a role, maybe even a big one. I still think the financial performance is what made Gunn and Safran vulnerable in the first place. If their slate had been making the studio a ton of money, I doubt we'd be having this conversation.
Ultimately, yeah. Humans always have biases (and politics is a prominent bias everyone has) and I do think it's naive to suggest they never play a role in stuff like this.
Like I said above, I do believe Jamie Kellner hated pro wrestling, and that led to him cancelling WCW programming on TNT and TBS in 2001.
But I also think that money is an overriding concern for most people, especially in a corporate environment where "make the line go up" is a constant pressure. Especially in the case of Skydance, which has a lot of debt to work through as a result of the Paramount/WB merger.
Do the more conservative powers that be in this new company have preferred someone more willing to toe their line running DC Studios? Probably. It's naive to suggest they wouldn't.
Would they act on it if Gunn's DC projects were raking in billions? No. Just like I'm sure Kellner wouldn't have let his hatred of pro wrestling lead him to shutting down WCW if it was still making $30 million a year instead of losing $60 million.
Like it's hard to see any corporate environment where Gunn is stepped down if he's delivering stronger box offices. Everyone would suddenly be talking about how a diversity of political opinions leads to stronger storytelling or some such if Gunn's movies were making bank.
But of the three DC Studios pictures under Gunn's tenure, Superman is the only clear success and even that came in under Snyder's Man of Steel, which was itself seen as a bit of a letdown.
Supergirl bombed worse then a movie that's a meme for how bad it bombed, and Clayface looks like it'll just barely break even.
Whether that means Skydance leadership used this as an opening to oust Gunn and act on their political biases, or that Gunn's under performance at the box office simply meant the money didn't justify keeping him on and that just happens to line up with politics, at the end of the day it boils down to the same thing... Gunn didn't perform financially at a level necessary to stick around.
Now I will say this in defence of Gunn. I think Skydance may need to re-adjust their expectations. The heyday of superhero cinema is likely behind us for the time being, so something like Superman 2025's box office is probably the most realistic high end return you can expect, short of like... a TDK-level Batman hit that gets butts in seats.
Expecting MCU Spider-Man or Avengers money across the board- especially for a brand as tarnished in cinemas like DC- likely isn't realistic for the time being. It falls on the studio to recognize that and adjust budgets accordingly so a return like Superman 2025 can be more profitable.
Now all of THAT being said... you can't just float a dud like Supergirl out there and not expect some sort of blowback. Like... come on. Less than
MORBIUS!