I really like Strongarm and how she turned out, I think she's the best looking version of that Mold. I also don't use it for Elita (Also a Jet Elita stan), but I just hate the car mode for it. I mentioned it previously but its not "it's not a porche" when it comes to Minvera. It's that it just looks bad. It looks like the car Homer Simpson designed. Strongarm could be bigger or bulkier, but to me she fixes the main issues with the mold.
I also prefer Jet Elita (and for her to not be half the size of Optimus). I think Strongarm makes the mold work best because her altmode is
supposed to have the blocker, wider back half. Hell, she might be the reason the mold even HAS that in vehicle mode, because neither of the other two designs have ever needed it.
I'm in full agreement with you that the Elita and Minerva versions look more like The Homer than either of their original/actual looks. "The Homer" was my exact thought as I looked at Minerva (my first copy of the mold) and saw a car front half with a bubble top welded to a truck back half, with the squat proportions and round vs boxy clash making it worse than Earthspark Bumblebee, who has a similar "boxy rear half of car" issue. (As with Side Burn, I don't need Minerva to be Specifically A Licensed Porsche, just not a car that looks this dumb.)
Strongarm wears the vehicle mode well, and that color scheme looks good on damn near anything. But she necessarily inherits the proportions of the other two, so it's less Strongarm than I'd like (plus the bumper-shoulders are a bit clunkier than I'd like). Maybe if they'd let Minerva be her own thing -- or, you know, have Nightbeat, her built-in mold relative, as her retooling batchmate -- and paired up Strongarm and an
EarthSpark style Elita instead. But of course that assumes there can even
be more than one base mold, so it's all moot.
I don't know. I'm actually oddly impressed at the ambition of
wanting to wring these three distinct and disparate characters out of one mold, but they're just too different for it to be a success.
...You know, if they'd just grouped Elita, Minerva, and
Shadow Striker, they could have a sleeker/less blocky altmode with no incongruous back half. The hood on the back can work as is for the first two and give Shadow Striker a frankensteined vehicle hood and single-color chest. Their proportions are all relatively closer to each other. Still three female characters, still a non-G1 third. Just shelf Strongarm until she can have her own mold to anchor -- although I can see the eureka moment of "Minerva's standing shoulder bits can work as horizontal shoulder bits for Strongarm" being HARD to resist, it's the only thing that works for both. This is a better retool base for Shadow Striker and Side Burn can fully own his mold -- there are still redeco/retool options for that.