So, how necessary is the main quest line?

wonko the sane?

You may test that assumption at your convinience.
Citizen
Alright, hear me out:

I've been thinking on bethesda style games. Where they build (or used to, anyway.) the semblance of a living world. And in that context: how necessary actually is the main quest? Does the player character have to be the worlds protagonist? Do you actually have to change the world in a large, deliberate, scripted way? Is just having a big enough variety of side quests sufficient to make a good game?

Cause, in my own experiences: the pressure of the main quest line, especially in skyrim, doesn't actually help. I feel guilty for getting distracted and doing side quests, and IF I ever get around to doing the main quest: I'm usually powerfully over-levelled and equipped even with whatever level scaling is implemented.

Which gets me wondering if a game designed like a bethesda game would work as a functional living world for an almost "cozy" combat and questing game: where you run around, clearing out caves and mines, looting old tombs, and maybe even some form of "gang warfare" system (think like GTA san andreas.) where ultimately the goal is to just... pay rent and build a legend.
 

Caldwin

Hey! Listen!
Citizen
I mean, my first time playing Oblivion, I never did finish the main quest, not because I couldn't...I just didn't want to lock myself out of more Sigil Stones. I finished it my second time around because "eh, might as well."

Skyrim, I finished the main quest three times at least and every time it just kinda felt like finishing another sidequest.

Honestly, it's not the first time I've heard this question and the answer is usually "not important at all."

Though I must stress this pertains almost entirely on Bethesda styled games.
 

wonko the sane?

You may test that assumption at your convinience.
Citizen
Which is why I stressed bethesda style games. I'm not saying that story driven, single player experiences aren't perfectly valid: but do we need the main quest in a sandbox
 

CoffeeHorse

Hanging in there
Staff member
Council of Elders
Citizen
My vote is yes, so long as it's a genuine CYOA quest with more differences than just the ending.
 

wonko the sane?

You may test that assumption at your convinience.
Citizen
I mean, it might be fairly hard to make actual CYOA radiant quests... but if you combine it with a turf war system in which the raiders aren't just decorative ablative meat to farm XP...
 

ZakuConvoy

Well-known member
Citizen
...Aren't you just describing a MMO?

I mean, I know MMOs also have story quests, but they're usually not the main draw. It really is "gameplay over progression".

So, yeah, sure. You can probably have a game that's all sidequests with no real story. Arguably, a lot of sandbox games already do that. Or at least lean heavily towards it. There's even some games like Rune Factory that get pretty close to what you're describing.
 

The Mighty Mollusk

Scream all you like, 'cause we're all mad here
Citizen
...Aren't you just describing a MMO?

I mean, I know MMOs also have story quests, but they're usually not the main draw. It really is "gameplay over progression".
Depends on the MMO, really. To use two of the biggest names in the genre, World of Warcraft doesn't particularly care if you follow through the main story in order too much, while Final Fantasy XIV is very much story-driven.
 

Pocket

jumbled pile of person
Citizen
The problem is that if there is no main quest, then there's no way to say "The End, roll credits" in a game with a finite amount of stuff to do. Assuming you don't quit before the end because you get bored or lose interest or get distracted by the Thnikkaman, you'll just run out of quests at some point and then... nothing. The world doesn't react in any way, but there's nothing left to do, no one left with anything new to say, you have to quit on your own. Sure, people who leave sidequests unfinished until after the main quest and then go back to do them are still going to have that experience, but that was on them for doing things out of order. It wasn't the intended experience.

On the flip side, I will never not resent Notch for putting an "end boss" in Minecraft complete with epilogue. That's supposed to be the antithesis of traditional games, a pure sandbox where there are no goals except the ones you set for yourself. But it was actually designed to be that. The infinite malleability of the world means a creative player can always think of more projects to engage in, more things to plan and gather resources for and build. Most games can't do that. Most games shouldn't try. The "Radiant quest" nonsense in early Elder Scrolls games turned out to be a dead end, and even modern generative AI couldn't fabricate infinite content in a game with a finitely-sized manmade world and assets.

The only other option would be an indefinite supply of new quests via regular DLC drops, similar to MMO expansions. Those could come with additions to the world map, new fully voiced characters, and everything, and even be contingent on completing other quests first rather than trying to squeeze more and more trigger points into the existing map or having a dozen quest popups in a row near the very start of the game if you bought the Game of the Year Edition.
 


Top Bottom