6718 replies to this topic

[TheBruteSlayer]

I didn't see a thread about him that wasn't old or even an official disscusion, so I made this thread.

For those who are unaware of him, Nostalgia Critic is a character
played by reviewer Doug Walker who reviews bad (and some good) nostalgic movies and TV shows.
He has tackled some of the worst movies there are such as Batman and Robin, the (poorly) animated Titanic movies,
Battlefield Earth, and the horrendously awful Garbage Pail Kids.

His latest review:

Nostalgia Critic: Star Trek 3 - The search for Spock


Full list of reviews here

I'll try to update this thread every week with his latest video.

[2019]

His "reviews" are awful.

[TheBruteSlayer]

His "reviews" are awful.

If you don't like him then you shouldn't have even bothered posting.

[2019]

Mother always said, "if you don't have anything nice to say, don't say it to your boss."

Then she lit up a cigarette and read a book.

[Cheetimus Primal]

It's an opinion spoken on a message board. Just because you don't agree doesn't mean you can tell someone not to post.

I also love NC! The recent delays were driving me crazy.

[Caldwin]

I've seen pretty much all if not all of his reviews. Love them. Even when he's ripping into a show I happen to like (Captain N was a fun show durnit!), usually I still find it funny just because I can't deny it's true.

[Ms Virion]

I prefer Brad Jones myself. Doug's alright, though frankly I think he's best when he's not 'on script'.

[TheBruteSlayer]

It's an opinion spoken on a message board. Just because you don't agree doesn't mean you can tell someone not to post.

sorry, I just can't stand it when someone just comes to express hate in front of fans.
Usually on TFW, a post like that led to a war. I respect his opinion.

[WorkbenchManiac]

NC is fun, although sometimes grating.

I prefer Spoony, to be honest.

[DeadPigmon]

NC can be hit and miss sometimes. don't know how a guy can get so many viruses to get delays in this day and age.

I hate 90% of the other people on that site. I like Spooney, FilmBrain (sometimes) and Vangelus but everyone else bores me to tears with their little mini stories they try to insert into a damn review.



I don't want to see some god damn terrible live action fanfiction in a review.

[Eva Sigma]

I like the Cinema Snob and Spoony the best, they review my kind of movies.

Z grade schlock starring people who haven't ever had a career or had their career majorly hit the skids!

[AnkhChalice]

NC can be hit and miss sometimes. don't know how a guy can get so many viruses to get delays in this day and age.

I hate 90% of the other people on that site. I like Spooney, FilmBrain (sometimes) and Vangelus but everyone else bores me to tears with their little mini stories they try to insert into a damn review.



I don't want to see some god damn terrible live action fanfiction in a review.

I couldn't agree more! I can't stand when people put storylines into their reviews, Linkara got really about that. I stopped watching his stuff completely, that and he comes off as whiny in my opinion.

[Eva Sigma]

NC can be hit and miss sometimes. don't know how a guy can get so many viruses to get delays in this day and age.

I hate 90% of the other people on that site. I like Spooney, FilmBrain (sometimes) and Vangelus but everyone else bores me to tears with their little mini stories they try to insert into a damn review.



I don't want to see some god damn terrible live action fanfiction in a review.

I couldn't agree more! I can't stand when people put storylines into their reviews, Linkara got really about that. I stopped watching his stuff completely, that and he comes off as whiny in my opinion.

Linkara is the only guy I've seen who has subplots, but then again, I don't watch everyone's videos.

Can't say I care about the Blockbuster Buster or Diamanda Hagan or Oancitizen or Phelous or Nash or any of those other guys.

[TM2-Megatron]

Looks like all this month they're going to be doing the odd-numbered Trek flicks.

[DeadPigmon]

NC can be hit and miss sometimes. don't know how a guy can get so many viruses to get delays in this day and age.

I hate 90% of the other people on that site. I like Spooney, FilmBrain (sometimes) and Vangelus but everyone else bores me to tears with their little mini stories they try to insert into a damn review.



I don't want to see some god damn terrible live action fanfiction in a review.

I couldn't agree more! I can't stand when people put storylines into their reviews, Linkara got really about that. I stopped watching his stuff completely, that and he comes off as whiny in my opinion.

Linkara is the only guy I've seen who has subplots, but then again, I don't watch everyone's videos.

Can't say I care about the Blockbuster Buster or Diamanda Hagan or Oancitizen or Phelous or Nash or any of those other guys.

there is the occasional other one on the site but I mean in general with reviewers. hell even toy reviewers do it >.>

[Eva Sigma]

NC can be hit and miss sometimes. don't know how a guy can get so many viruses to get delays in this day and age.

I hate 90% of the other people on that site. I like Spooney, FilmBrain (sometimes) and Vangelus but everyone else bores me to tears with their little mini stories they try to insert into a damn review.



I don't want to see some god damn terrible live action fanfiction in a review.

I couldn't agree more! I can't stand when people put storylines into their reviews, Linkara got really about that. I stopped watching his stuff completely, that and he comes off as whiny in my opinion.

Linkara is the only guy I've seen who has subplots, but then again, I don't watch everyone's videos.

Can't say I care about the Blockbuster Buster or Diamanda Hagan or Oancitizen or Phelous or Nash or any of those other guys.

there is the occasional other one on the site but I mean in general with reviewers. hell even toy reviewers do it >.>

Not any toy reviewers I watch.

Unless you count Vangelus' themed reviews.

[DeadPigmon]

NC can be hit and miss sometimes. don't know how a guy can get so many viruses to get delays in this day and age.

I hate 90% of the other people on that site. I like Spooney, FilmBrain (sometimes) and Vangelus but everyone else bores me to tears with their little mini stories they try to insert into a damn review.



I don't want to see some god damn terrible live action fanfiction in a review.

I couldn't agree more! I can't stand when people put storylines into their reviews, Linkara got really about that. I stopped watching his stuff completely, that and he comes off as whiny in my opinion.

Linkara is the only guy I've seen who has subplots, but then again, I don't watch everyone's videos.

Can't say I care about the Blockbuster Buster or Diamanda Hagan or Oancitizen or Phelous or Nash or any of those other guys.

there is the occasional other one on the site but I mean in general with reviewers. hell even toy reviewers do it >.>

Not any toy reviewers I watch.

Unless you count Vangelus' themed reviews.

oh no no no Vangelus' reviews are awesome. Dat sexy voice...

and I don't want to start naming names in case I offend people ;P

[Detour]

I enjoy a lot of people on That Guy With The Glasses. NC himself, of course, Spoony, Cinema Snob, Linkara, Film Brain...

And the anniversary films, Kickassia and Suburban Knights, are in my opinion comedy gold.

[Boo]

I prefer Film Brain and Phelous, but yeah, Nostalgia Critic is pretty cool. I spend way too much time on that site...

[Ms Virion]

Nash is really underrated. He's got good charisma, a great voice (and a high quality set up) and works really well with the other reviewers. Plus he avoids the storyline pitfalls.