Judge a Person by Their Avatar

[Wheelimus]

JUSTICE FOR TIGATRON.

 

[Guardian Prime]

A poker face carved from stone.

 

[Caldwin]

And over here is an exact replica of Ponyville. It was built in less than a minute.

Why do you have an exa...?

We don't talk about it.

 

[Swerve]

ummm...you have something in your eye....

 

[Caldwin]

How's he supposed to fit that in his chest? It's as big as he is!

By the way, if it helps any, mine is Carmilla from the early Castlevania games where instead of actually being a vampire, she was just represented as a mask.

 

[The Mighty Mollusk]

 

[Guardian Prime]

Looks like The Tick got out of the wrong side of the bed today.

 

[MadameVixen]

Adorable avatar. Good taste

 

[Princess Viola]

bat cat anthro furry thing or something idk.

 

[MadameVixen]

bat cat anthro furry thing or something idk.

Pauca Billee. Its a cryptid getting its name from the Hindi words for winged and cat with some reports saying it resembles a cat mixed with a bat.
So you are close
I'm guessing inflatable cat furry with a witches hat?

 

[CoffeeHorse]

Ratbat's lesser known rival: Catbat.

 

[The Mighty Mollusk]

Sleipnir's lesser-known little brother, Slurpnir.

 

[Guardian Prime]

The Tick's alter ego when he's in a really bad mood.

 

[CoffeeHorse]

Spoilers for IDW's next miniseries.

 

[Princess Viola]

that first sip of the day

 

[Guardian Prime]

That first scratch to my face of the day.

 

[MadameVixen]

First aww how cute of the day

 

[Princess Viola]

only cryptids i consider real are tsuchinoko and chupacabras

 

[Sharkshadow]

offbrand megaman minion.

 

[MadameVixen]

Ok I must know...
Sharkpuppy fan?