It's a good point, and if this show took more of a BTAS approach- a fantasy world that just leans into 30s-40s aesthetics but clearly isn't that era- I'd not be tilting my head at it.That *is* quite jarring, unlike the Howitzer Umbrella mounted on a cruise ship and the literal Cat car which the 30-40’s were absolutely rife with…
I’ve noticed “realism” especially in otherwise fantastical properties is almost always used to justify absolute shit things like bigotry and racism (or Section 31)
It’s fake so if you can believe a dude dresses in a leotard to fight crime you can believe people didn’t have a problem with LGBTQ relationships.
EDIT: I’m not accusing you of wishing that or anything just to be clear.
My issue comes from being both a progressive person and a history teacher. A lot of the issues faced by both LGBTQ+ peoples and racial minorities in the US are rooted in centuries of systemic bigotry. You need to understand the histories to understand the modern issues these groups face, and you need to reckon with these histories before you can fully move to fix the damage. I take that part of my job as an educator incredibly seriously.
To be clear a Batman tv show is under no obligation to be a history lesson or replace schooling in general but at the same time it was a conscious effort to set this show in the mid-20th century yet make it conform to our standards of progressiveness when it comes to LGBTQ+ rights and race relations.
If a kid sees this show and decides that African Americans couldn't have had it so bad if Black Jim Gordon could be police commissioner or that sexual and gender minorities don't have it so bad if open Lesbian relationships were seen as no big deal pre-WWII then...
eh
Anyone coming into my classroom spouting that stuff off will get their record set straight, but I'm not looking at the state of our education system as-is and feeling super confident in that being the case across the board.
I don't think Black Jim Gordon or openly Queer folk are bad in Batman by any means. And hell, go the BTAS route if you want to do that stuff and keep your pulpy feel... but something about pretending like everything was a-ok for LGBTQ+ peoples and racial minorities in a 1930s-1940s setting just doesn't sit right with me. I understand the good intentions of the creators, but I think it's one of those "does more harm then they intended" sorts of things.
Aside from all of that...
His Bruce Wayne persona basically is! Right down to him being mean to his butlerThis show's design for Bruce Wayne makes him look like Sterling Archer.